Skip to main content

Revisiting the Disc – A Review of “Equal Rites” by Terry Pratchett


Equal Rites is the third book in Terry Pratchett’s incredibly long running Discworld series and unlike the other Discworld books that I have recently re-read (Going Postal, The Colour of Magic, Mort and Guards, Guards! – reviewed here) it’s not one of the books I had many memories about. And I think I can see why, because in many ways Equal Rites is an awkward transition novel from the High Fantasy parody of the original first two novels into the more mainstream comic low fantasy novels (with a strong moral weight) that became the standard Discworld formula.

So what is the story of Equal Rites? In short, just before his death a wizard hands his staff to his heir – an eighth son of an eighth son –  only to find out that the baby he gave the staff to was actually a girl, which is impossible as everyone knows women can’t be wizards. The girl (Esk) then grows up, shows she has magical powers and is taken by Granny Weatherwax, the local witch, for training. However Esk’s magic proves to be wizard magic - a different beast from witch magic - and so her and Granny end up on a journey to Ankh-Morpork to enroll Esk in the Unseen University i.e. wizard school. On the way they have a number of adventures, and despite initially being barred from joining the school, Esk is eventually allowed in after she stops quantum horror invading the world.

This is a book I’m conflicted about. Some of it is really funny – the wizards duel in particular which is straight out of Disney’s Sword in the Stone – Granny Weatherwax is fun in all her scenes and some of the world building is very clever such as the idea of witches magic being 0.1% magic and 99.9%  common sense (which doesn’t seem powerful until you remember that common sense isn’t actually that common). On the other hand, I did find that this was not as sharp a novel as the latter Discworld books, much of the story is quite episodic and I think the travelling adventures are far less interesting then the early scenes in the Ramtops or when they are at Unseen University. Also, if I’m honest I did find the attempt at quantum magic during the book’s finale to be a bit naff. (Terry Pratchett regularly tried to add elements of science fantasy to his very early Discworld novel and like the dimension hopping in The Colour of Magic I felt that the quantum magic gimmick was very out of place)

Ultimately Equal Rites is still a very fun read and if you like Terry Pratchett then you absolutely should do so. But if you’ve never read him, I don’t think this is a strong enough novel to recommend wholeheartedly. Instead you’d be better off by picking up book four in the series Mort as if Equal Rites is Pratchett learning how to write the modern Discworld novel, Mort is where he perfected the model.

 Today's Soundtrack - "A Wizard's Staff Has a Knob at the End" by Dave Greenslade


 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Herein starts the much-promised blog by Mr Stephen J Watt MA, of origins from the Parish of Fraserburgh in the old County of Aberdeen. Universally loved for his humble wisdom and reserved persona, he has kindly deigned to come out of obscurity by allowing the publication of his thoughts on this here blog. The editors of the blog would, therefore, wish to publicly thank him for his dedication to this task, and the willingness he has shown to sacrifice his time and effort into this endeavour. Furthermore, they can only hope that this blog shall be a testament to the character of the Scottish nation and a source of inspiration for all future generations."               -Stephen Watt (Chair of The Watt Blog Committee), 2019 ... ... ... Right presumably  I've lost most potential readers with that pretentious introduction and so I can now address  you, the sole remaining reader, directly. I assume you have some questions? Actually,...
2 comments
Read more

Where The Referendums Never Stop - A Review of "Why Switzerland?" by Jonathan Steinberg

Why Switzerland? by Jonathan Steinberg is a 1996 non-fiction text that aims to answer the question of why Switzerland culture and political structures are so unique compared to its European neighbours. Why did I read Why Switzerland? that’s simple – I’d always heard that Switzerland was famously decentralised and used referendums all the time, but barely knew anything about the country other than chocolate, clocks and banks so I wanted to find out more. But why Why Switzerland? in particular? That’s even easier, it was the only English language book I could find that covered the topic without being either a travelogue or a very dry political science treatise. It seems that Switzerland, if Glasgow libraries are to be believed, is a rather obscure country. But anyway, onto the review! Why Switzerland? is in many ways a very old-fashioned attempt at summarising the essence of a country in a book. Its aim is to summarise why Switzerland exists and what makes it uniquely Swiss. It does t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Fairies and Shamans in My Scotland? – The Secret Commonwealth by Robert Kirk

The Secret Commonwealth or A Treatise Displaying the Chief Curousities among the People of Scotland as they are in Use to This Day by the Reverand Robert Kirk is a famous study on 17 th century folk beliefs where Kirk sums up many of the beliefs around faeries and the second sight prevalent amongst his parishioners in 1690s Aberfoyle. It’s a book I remember hearing about during my undergraduate at Aberdeen, but at the time the only copy was in the Heavy Demand section, and so it was only this year that I finally managed to get a hold of a copy of the Folklore Society edition edited by Stewart Sanderson from my local university library in Glasgow. Or at least, I thought that I had taken out the Folklore Society version – what I had actually taken out was the edition by ceremonial magician and occultist R J Stewart . Realising I had made a mistake I did eventually take out the Folklore Society version as well, so in a rare treat the Alt Clud Review of Books is reviewing two books for...
Post a Comment
Read more